Skip navigation
Ram overwhelmed competitors in September with 29 sales leap
<p><strong>Ram overwhelmed competitors in September with 29% sales leap.</strong></p>

Ram’s September Surprise Could Ignite Truck War

Ram overtaking the Chevrolet Silverado for second place in light-truck sales in September, combined with growing pickup inventories, may be a harbinger of an all-out truck sales war in last-quarter 2016.

A Clinton (Bill) was president the last time the Ram pickup truck brand leapfrogged General Motors’ Chevrolet Silverado to jump into the silver-medal spot in the monthly truck sales race.

It’s been 17 years since that remarkable event back in July 1999, when the then-Dodge brand whomped Silverado by 6,893 units in light-duty pickup sales, WardsAuto data shows. In September, Ram pulled off the same feat, albeit by a more modest 739 units this time around, selling 46,119 trucks to Chevy’s 45,380.

Ram pickup sales were up 29.2% in September, overtaking Silverado which dropped 15.5% compared with year-ago levels. For the year, Silverado is off by 3.5% at 425,556 sales through September and Ram is up 8.1% at 346,107. The Ford F-150 dipped 3.4% for the month, but maintained its hold on first place in pickup sales in September, moving 62,912 units. F-Series sales are up 5% to 553,486 for the year.

“Our September pickup truck sales are a good illustration of how the Ram Truck brand is drawing customers with great product,” Jim Morrison, head of Ram Truck-FCA North America, says. “Our pickup-truck customers are attracted to Ram’s quality, reliability and durability. America’s longest-lasting pickups offer great value along with class-exclusive features like load-leveling air suspension, RamBox and best-in-class fuel economy with the 29-mpg (8.1 L/100 km) EcoDiesel trucks.”

What Morrison doesn’t say is a spike in incentives on Ram compared with a year ago may have juiced September sales, with some industry observers suggesting FCA may have wanted to boost sales numbers and improve its bottom line closing out the third quarter. According to J.D. Power data reported by Bloomberg, incentives on Ram jumped $1,000 from a year earlier to an average $7,082 per vehicle.

Data from online automotive marketplace TrueCar shows a smaller but similar $887 year-over-year increase to $5,178 average incentive per vehicle, with GMC Sierra showing a $2,099 jump, second only to the $2,707 leap by the Nissan Titan. TrueCar data shows Silverado incentives up $601 year-over-year. Incentive estimates differ among reporting agencies due to a variance in sources of aggregated data.

In defense of Morrison’s marketing theory, incentives on Ram grew just $29 from August to September, while Sierra was up $1,496, Silverado $184 and F-Series $301.

It is unclear whether Ram can sustain its momentum, or whether FCA will want it to, given that Ram inventory is down 21% from August to September, hovering at an 82-day supply, WardsAuto data shows. Ram’s inventory was high in August, however, and in raw numbers the fullsize pickup still appears to be stocked about 20,000 units too high.

Silverado is running at 91 days’ supply, up 16%, while F-Series sits on a 93-day inventory, unchanged from the prior month. Overall, the large-pickup segment inventory is 11.1% above year-ago at 87 days’ supply.

WardsAuto considers a 90-day supply of fullsize pickups optimum on average for the year and for Sept. 30 inventory. The number historically grows to 95 days in October, 100 in November and 75 in December when end-of-year sell-downs and reduced production due to holidays cut into supply.

While Ram and Silverado inventories are above year-ago, only Ram is selling better than like-2015, while the light-truck segment overall has declined 6.3%.

If Ram’s strength continues, it may provoke an all-out war in the pickup segment as Chevy reacts to protect its turf, Ford fights back with its all-new Super Duty, Nissan battles for sales with a newly redesigned Titan and Toyota tosses more Tundras into the fray, adding inventory after shifting production to building more Tacoma small pickups.

Small-Truck Factor

Small trucks also may be cannibalizing fullsize pickup volume. Although WardsAuto data shows small pickups historically do best in the second quarter, GM’s re-entry into the segment two years ago with the Chevy Colorado and GMC Canyon reignited demand. That along with fresh versions of the Honda Ridgeline and Tacoma, and Nissan’s efforts to remain viable with the Frontier, suggest the segment may post its strongest quarter in October-December this year.

Automakers are cagey about plans for production changes or sales deals as they head into the fourth quarter.

“We’re prepared to respond to market factors, but we don’t consider price the single lever,” says Alan Batey, GM executive vice president and president-North America. “If you offer those sorts of incentives you will get a short-term boost. We will stay disciplined.”

“We’re lean and mean, unlike some of our competitors,” Batey says of GM’s truck inventory. “We’re in a good position (to close the year).”

Ford’s supply level is good going into the year-end push, especially with the newest trucks in the market recording the highest average transaction prices, says Erich Merkle, the automaker’s U.S. sales analyst.

“We’re going to continue to maintain a disciplined but competitive approach to our incentive spending,” Merkle says.

with James M. Amend

[email protected] @bobgritzinger


Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.